Chili is an American favorite and a signature dish in our house during football season. It is classic family dinner that varies by family and region to region. It is also a versatile dish that allows you to play with toppings, flavors, and how you serve it. For this recipe, I am sharing my favorite go-to chili which is technically a Cincinnati-style chili recipe. However, I never serve it over spaghetti. I simply find the flavors of Cincinnati chili to be the best.
The result is a chili that is a little different from your traditional bowl of chili. It has a rich, savory flavor with a subtle complexity that makes it stand out from other chili recipes. I like that it is still comforting, satisfying meal but has a unique flavor profile that makes it something a little different from the usual weeknight chili. It also one of those recipes that is easy to make your own depending on how you decide to serve it.
In our house, we often serve this chili on its own with simple toppings like shredded cheese and Fritos. We also use it to make chili fries and top hot dogs, which makes for an especially fun game-night dinner. For Halloween, I serve this chili alongside mummy hotdogs. This chili is easy enough to make on a weeknight or even just before you head out trick-or-treating.
What Makes This Recipe Work
- Warm spices. Adding cinnamon and allspice alongside chili powder, cumin, and oregano gives this chili its unique flavor. It is just enough to know there is something different without overwhelming the chili or making the flavor seem unusual. It is perfect for fall but delicious all year long.
- Ground turkey. Using ground turkey makes this chili feel a little lighter while still delivering plenty of flavor. It also holds up surprisingly well in this recipe, maintaining a nice texture throughout the cooking process.
- Chocolate. Adding chocolate at the end of cooking gives the chili a subtle hint of sweetness and an added depth of flavor. It is a small ingredient that makes a difference in the finished dish. My family can always tell when I forget to add it!
- Versatile Toppings. Whether you keep it simple with shredded cheese or add Fritos for a little crunch, the toppings let everyone make their bowl their own. You can also take it beyond a traditional bowl of chili and use it for chili fries or hot dogs.

Cincinnati Chili
Ingredients
Method
- Heat oil in large dutch oven over medium heat. Add ground turkey and crumble. Cook for 3 minutes or until turkey is nearly done. Add onions and green bell pepper. Season with salt and pepper. Cook until onions are translucent about 3 minutes.

- Add garlic and cook for 30 seconds. Add spices and tomato sauce, and stir to combine. Cook for 1 minute.

- Add chicken broth, kidney beans, and diced tomatoes, and stir to combine.

- Bring to a simmer and cook for 20 minutes until more for a sauce like consistency.

- Stir in chocolate and season with salt to taste.

- Serve with handful of shredded sharp cheese or your favorite toppings.


Leave a Reply